A pie crust blind baking in the oven, lined with parchment and filled with dried peas as pie weights

Par Bake vs Blind Bake vs Half Blind (Plus Our Bakery Crust)

Par bake, blind bake or half blind? Which one your pie needs, a free cheat sheet, and the bakery crust that only needs 10 minutes, no weights.

Skip to recipe ↓
The short answer
  • Blind bake (full): crust baked empty with pie weights until golden and done. For fillings that never go in the oven: cream pies, lemon curd, ganache, fresh fruit tarts.
  • Half blind (partial blind bake): same weights, but you stop when it's set and still pale. For wet fillings that bake in the crust: quiche, pumpkin, custard.
  • Par bake: a short bake, no weights. At the bakery our crust goes in empty for 10 minutes, then gets filled. We do it for juicy fruit pies like blueberry and apple, or the bottom goes soggy.

People use these two words like they mean the same thing, and honestly they kind of do. Both mean the crust goes in the oven before the filling. The difference is how far you take it. And the one thing that decides it for you is the filling. Does it bake in the crust or not? Answer that and you know which one you need.

Blind baking is the technique. How far you take it is the difference.

Download my free cheat sheet (PDF) with all three side by side, plus our bakery crust recipe.

Why pre-bake a crust at all

A raw crust under a wet filling never gets the heat it needs. The filling sits on top like a cold blanket, the moisture soaks down, and you end up with a pale, gummy, soggy bottom. Baking the crust first sets the starches and fat, drives off some water, and gives you a crisp layer that the filling can't soak through. It also stops the sides from slumping down into the pan before they set.

Half blind: for wet fillings that bake in the crust

A half blind bake, or partial blind bake, takes the crust about halfway. It's set, it's dry to the touch, it's barely starting to color, but it's not done. Then you fill it and both finish together. This is for wet, liquid fillings that need to bake but set faster than a raw crust can cook through.

  • Quiche
  • Pumpkin and sweet potato pie
  • Custard and chess style pies
  • Pecan style pies

How I do it: 375°F. Line the chilled crust with parchment, fill it to the top with pie weights or dry beans, and bake about 15 minutes until the edges are set. Pull the weights and parchment, bake another 5 minutes to dry out the bottom, then fill and finish.

Full blind bake: for fillings that never see the oven

If the filling goes in cold, the crust has to be 100% done before it gets filled. Nothing is going to finish it later.

  • Cream pies (chocolate, banana, coconut)
  • Lemon curd and lime tarts
  • Chocolate ganache tarts
  • Fresh fruit and pastry cream tarts

How I do it: same start, 375°F with parchment and weights for about 15 to 20 minutes. Then pull the weights and keep going another 10 to 15 minutes, until the bottom is golden and dry all the way across, not just the edges. Let it cool completely before you fill it, or you're just steaming it all over again.

A glossy lemon tart in a fully baked crust next to fresh lemons

Par bake: for juicy fruit pies

A lot of recipes tell you to put apple or blueberry straight into a raw crust. But fruit lets out a lot of juice as it bakes, and all of it runs straight to the bottom. At the bakery our crust goes in for 10 minutes first, every time, especially for something wet like blueberry or apple. Then fill it, and bake it on the lowest rack so the bottom gets direct heat.

A slice of blueberry pie with a juicy filling on a blue plate

Cheat sheet

FillingMethodCrust when you fill it
Bakes in the crust, wet (quiche, pumpkin, custard)Half blindSet and dry, pale
Never baked (cream, curd, ganache, fresh fruit)Full blind bakeGolden and fully done
Juicy fruit (apple, blueberry)Par bake, 10 minSet and pale, low rack

Tips from the bakery

  • Chill before it goes in. A cold crust holds its shape. A warm one slumps the second the fat melts.
  • Weights all the way to the top. Fill them right up to the rim so the sides are supported, not just the bottom.
  • Dock the bottom (fork holes). Prick it all over with a fork so steam can escape and the bottom doesn't puff up.
  • Seal it. For a really wet filling, brush the half baked crust with a thin wash and give it 2 more minutes to set a barrier. My vegan egg wash replacements work great for this.

The crust we use at the bakery

Here's the thing. At the bakery we make pies and quiches all day, and we never mess with parchment and beans. Our crust goes in empty for 10 minutes, then we fill it. No gluten, so there's nothing to shrink back down the sides, and no weights needed. And the oat flour and starches set fast, so 10 minutes is all it takes to seal the bottom. This is our recipe, scaled down from the bakery batch to one 9-inch crust.

Sensible Bakery Pie & Quiche Crust

Yield

One 9″ crust

Prep time

15 min + 30 min chill

Par bake

10 min

Bake temp

375°F

An empty pie shell pricked with fork holes in a fluted tart pan on a wooden table

Equipment

  • 9-inch pie dish
  • Rolling pin & parchment paper
  • Mixing bowl

Ingredients

IngredientAmountWeight
Oat flour (certified gluten-free)¾ cup + 2 tbsp80 g
Rice flour3 tbsp27 g
Potato starch3 tbsp27 g
Tapioca flour2 tbsp18 g
Brown sugar1 tbsp, packed15 g
Xanthan gum¼ tsp1 g
Salt¼ tsp1.5 g
Vegan butter, cold, in chunks¼ cup57 g
Ice cold water3½ tbsp53 g

Instructions

  1. Whisk the oat flour, rice flour, potato starch, tapioca, brown sugar, xanthan and salt together.
  2. Add the butter cold and in chunks. Rub or cut it in until the biggest pieces are about the size of peas. Those cold pieces are your flaky layers, so don't let them melt.
  3. Add the ice cold water and mix just until it comes together into a dough.
  4. Flatten it into a disc, wrap it, and chill it for at least 30 minutes.
  5. Roll it out between two sheets of parchment and lay it into your pie pan.
  6. Baked filling (quiche, pumpkin, custard, blueberry, apple): bake it empty at 375°F for 10 minutes, no weights. Then fill it and bake as your filling recipe says. No-bake filling (cream, curd, ganache): bake it empty at 375°F for about 15 minutes until golden, cool completely, then fill.

Want a version with no butter at all? My 3-ingredient pie crust is pressed in, so it doesn't puff or shrink either.

So next time a recipe says blind bake, ask yourself one thing: is this filling going in the oven? If it's wet and baked, half blind. If it's juicy fruit, par bake. If it never sees the oven, blind bake it all the way. Want more like this? Check out how to grease your pan like a pro baker and my apple spice pie.